You are a partner of Audit firm currently auditing Wellington Milk Products Ltd,

Question

You are a partner of Audit firm currently auditing Wellington Milk Products Ltd, a fast growing small size com you became aware that staff sold 500 kg milk chocolate and did not record the transactions in the company's accounting system. The proceeds from these sales are used to fund the firm's Christmas party pany. Due to your close relationship with the compan y directors and managers Required (a) What are the five fundamental principles you should comply with as a professional t? Please name and explain each principle. (10 Marks) (b) Who are the stakeholders that can be affected in this case? (4 Marks) Which three ethical theories can you use to solve the potential ethical dilemma? Please name each theory and explain for each theory the main principle by which an action is considered morally good. (c) (6 Marks)

Explanation / Answer

A) reply
The five essential ideas
1) Integrity
A legit accountant must be straightforward and sincere in all legit and industry relationships.
2) Objectivity
A professional accountant must now not permit bias, clash of interest or undue have an effect on of others to override legit or business judgments.
3) authentic competence and due care
A reliable accountant has a carrying on with responsibility to keep respectable knowledge and talent on the degree required to be certain that a purchaser or employer receives competent respectable offerings centered on current tendencies in apply, laws and techniques. A respectable accountant must act diligently and in keeping with relevant technical and reliable standards.
Four) Confidentiality
A reputable accountant should respect the confidentiality of knowledge received therefore of respectable and business relationships and should no longer reveal this kind of expertise to 3rd events without proper and unique authority until there's a authorized or legit right or responsibility to disclose. Private expertise bought for that reason of reliable and business relationships will have to no longer be used for the private expertise of the reliable accountant or 1/3 parties.
5) reputable behaviour
A authentic accountant should agree to relevant laws and regulations and should avoid any action that discredits the occupation.
C) reply
management knowledge


one of the crucial predominant leadership talents you could possess is a high ethical intelligence.
It may appear that bad habits is rewarded in the company world, but it's most commonly a very brief-term phenomenon. Within the lengthy-term, excellent habits tends to pay off.
What makes ethical dilemmas certainly complex is that they typically contain conflicts between two or extra deeply held beliefs. Recollect this admittedly easy illustration
A pal of yours simply had a child. He's the most homely baby you've ever seen. Whilst keeping her new little one boy in her palms, your friend asks, Isn't he the pleasant looking little one you've ever visible?
Now you value honesty. However you additionally feel you shouldn't needlessly damage someones feelings. You have an ethical difficulty!
Ethical dilemmas waft upward
everyone are leaders, even supposing it"s just personal management. Nevertheless, while you managing others, it's vital to have a framework in place to care for moral dilemmas. Leaders have to be taught to use their values, aligned with the values of their organization, to those circumstances. Ethical selections are mainly alternate-offs between:
Utility the value delivered to the stakeholders in your organization
Rights entitlement to whatever
Justice equitable sharing of suffering and pleasure
due to the fact that of those alternate-offs, leaders have to be all set to care for ethical dilemmas for the reason that these selections are likely to go with the flow upward. So leaders have got to improve a framework to handle these inevitable challenges.
The benefits of an founded framework
There are as a minimum four benefits to striking a framework in location for making moral selections:
efficiency choices can be made extra quickly
Consistency outcome in more systematic outputs
Payback builds emotional goodwill with your parts
Self-appreciate you believe good about your self when you seem in the replicate
three steps to solving moral dilemmas
#1 know your values
There are specified values about which society has the same opinion. For example, we are inclined to value honesty. Our dialogue right here isn't designed to change your values as a substitute, it's about applying them. Earlier than you could practice them, you need to comprehend what they're.
If you haven't formally meditated your values, or even supposing you haven't concept about it for awhile, determine out our article on core values.
Software: Create your list of core values.
#2 choose a mannequin
in line with the booklet, moral issues in trade, ethical theories can also be divided into two classifications: consequential theories (the formal time period for these is teleological theories) and non-consequential theories (formal identify is deontological theories).
The next just isn't a complete record of moral theories, but it surely certainly covers probably the most large ones for industry humans.
Consequential theories
With consequential theories, actions are judged by using results. If an action outcome in a positive outcome, it's morally right. If no longer, it is mistaken.
Egoism An act is ethical if it promotes your quality lengthy-time period curiosity.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
priceless for determination-making
Ignores wrongs
flexible
Ignores curiosity of others
Doesn't construct relationships
Inconsistent (i.E. Proper for me, mistaken for you)
Can't resolve conflicts of curiosity
Utilitarianism
An act is moral if it produces the fine ratio of fine to evil for all people.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
priceless for selection-making may ignore wrongs
flexible could conflict with justice
recognizes pursuits of all problematic to design rules
Resolves conflict of interest
Situational An act is ethical if it creates the greatest quantity of affection.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
Humanizes choices Lacks exact criteria for selection-making
Rejects moral legalism
Non-consequential theories
in line with non-consequential theories, a factor (single rule non-consequential theories) or reasons (multiple rule non-consequential theories) rather than the effect must be considered when confronted with an ethical problem.
Single rule
Golden Rule An act is moral if you happen to treat others the way you can wish to be handled.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSE Personalizes decisions desires amendment to fit commerce
Brings equity into play we can't know how others think and consider
incorporates childhood teachings into trade
categorical critical (Kant) An act is ethical for those who would wish that everybody behaved within the same manner.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
priceless for decisions (i.E. Do your obligation) Doesn't unravel conflicts of duties
acknowledges responsibilities subject to misinterpretation of responsibility
supplies humanistic dimension results of performing on duty may also be disastrous
Respects rights of others
more than one principles
Prima Facie duties (Ross) An act is moral in the event you fulfill your duties; if there's conflict, fulfill the responsibility to which you're most obligated. Prima facie responsibilities incorporate, however will not be constrained to: fidelity, gratitude, justice, beneficence, self-improvement, and non-injury.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
â list of responsibilities is educational in itself â elaborate to assess weight of obligations
â sensitive to penalties â No normal contract on ethical concepts
Maximin precept of Justice (Rawls) â An act is ethical if it supplies an equal amount of liberty for you and others, except when social or fiscal inequalities exist. If that's the case, the worst-off in society should advantage extra from the act.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
â indicates inherent respect for participants â concerned simplest with justice
â Encourages social accountability via all â Assumes a high level of rationality
â shows concern for much less fortunate â Assumes appearing without self-interest
Proportionality (Garrett) â An act is moral if, in carrying out it, you donât will a important evil to you or someone else and in the event you donât will, chance or permit a minor evil to your self or any individual else and not using a proportionate rationale.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
â Synthesizes most useful theories â Definitions are indistinct
â presents flexibility without immorality â totally subjective
You commonly observed that each one of those theories have weaknesses. So you can also believe that picking out an ethical theory is an activity in futility. Nevertheless, if you decide on the ethical thought that you simply feel is most intently aligned with your core values, youâll in finding solving ethical dilemmas a lot easier. Which you could recognize the weak spot of your system, whilst feeling confident in your method.
Application: decide on the moral concept which most intently aligns along with your values.
#three â Use a difficulty-solving method
Now you recognize your values and you have a model with which to apply them. The rest piece is to comply with an orderly procedure to clear up the main issue, on the grounds that not all moral dilemmas are as simple as your friend and her baby that we mentioned prior.
We endorse that you simply clear up IT! Thatâs our acronym for the timeless challenge-fixing approach. Whilst you comply with a system reminiscent of this to remedy an moral hassle, or any challenge for that topic, you feel just right about your superb determination. You know you've viewed all of the choices and chosen the fine alternative beneath the situations.

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse Y
• Subjects

---

---

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.