What are the relevant costs? What would be the effect on the company\'s overall
ID: 2406609 • Letter: W
Question
What are the relevant costs?
What would be the effect on the company's overall net operating income if product XRAY were dropped?
Should the product be dropped or kept? Why? Support your answer with at least one credible source other than your text.
Is it in the company’s best interest to close the XRAY facility? Why or why not? Be sure to explain your answer.
The Superman Corporation The Superman Corporation produces two products: XRAYTM sunglasses and NightVisionTM reading glasses. This corporation is considering dropping their XRAY sunglasses. If Superman discontinues their sunglasses, the company will close the XRAY factory in Kryptonite, Indiana. The plant, which originally cost $3.5M to build, employs 50 full time manufacturing employees and eight office workers. The factory is one of the largest employers in town, and it is unlikely that the manufacturing employees will find comparable work within 50 miles Additionally, since the plant was originally located on the outskirts of town, it was "grandfathered" in to the town's new zoning restrictions. Additionally, if the plant is closed, it cannot be sold to another manufacturing company. The land is worth about $150,000 Data from the company's annual report for last year is listed below Sales Variable Manufacturing Costs Contribution Margin Traceable Selling & Administration Expenses Product Line Segment Margin Common Fixed Costs Net Income (loss) Company $ 800,000 $ 440,000 $ 360,000 184,000 XRAY Night Vision 400,000 239,000 161,000 28,000 400,000 201,000 199,000 156,000 $ 176,000 248,000Explanation / Answer
Solution 1:
Relevant costs are avoidable cost that can be avoided on closing the plant.
Therefore relevant costs are Variable manufacturing costs and traceable selling and admin expenses of XRAY Division
= $201,000 + $156,000 = $357,000
Solution 2:
If Product X ray is dropped the loss of sales = $400,000
Benefit due to elimination of expenses = $357,000
Effect on overall operating income = $357,000 - $400,000 = -$43,000
Therefore overall net operating income will decrease by $43,000
Solution 3:
As there is decrease in operating income on dropping X ray product therefore Xray product should not be dropped.
Further company is not able to sell the plant and full time employee will not find jobs in market on dropping X ray product, therefore it is recommended to continue with Xray product line.
It is not interest of the company to close the Xray facility as it will resulting in decrease in overall net operating income by $43,000
Related Questions
drjack9650@gmail.com
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.