Academic Integrity: tutoring, explanations, and feedback — we don’t complete graded work or submit on a student’s behalf.

There are several companies (most notably 23andMe) providing SNP genotyping for

ID: 30799 • Letter: T

Question

There are several companies (most notably 23andMe) providing SNP genotyping for individuals claiming that there is no sense for individual in obtaining full genome sequence since only small part of it could be interpreted.

While this agrees with my understanding of the subject, I wonder whether there could be any use to perform full sequence of one's genome for means of personal health care?

The only effect I recall which affects individual's health and could not be caught by SNP genotyping is DNA methylation, but complete sequencing procedure does not detect it either, as far as I know.

Explanation / Answer

This difference would have the greatest impact on treatment for cancer, in which a treatment protocol is based on genes deleted, amplified, altered in the tumor vs the reference genome for that patient.

In terms of health risks based on SNP genotypes, the data are far from complete. Sure, some level of risk can be assigned to a variant (SNP), say at certain markers within the FTO gene and risk of obesity. However, the complete list of risk alleles for this and numerous other complex traits is not fully described. Furthermore, the impact of environmental factors (EF), or lifestyle choices, on those genetic variants is only beginning to gain wider attention. For example, a risk allele may not show itself as risk until the EF, such as amount of physical activity or percent energy from dietary polyunsaturated fat, passes a certain threshold. Such gene-environment interactions are thought to contribute to the variance in traits (phenotypes), but to what degree is not known.

Thus, in terms of personal healthcare outside of something like cancer and monogenetic disorders, there may be little that is gained from genotyping or complete genome sequencing, little that is compared to other advice you already know. I carry risk alleles for certain conditions, but there is not really any advice one can give me that is specific for those alleles that I have, where that advice is different than or goes beyond general advice health care providers already have dispensed.

Hire Me For All Your Tutoring Needs
Integrity-first tutoring: clear explanations, guidance, and feedback.
Drop an Email at
drjack9650@gmail.com
Chat Now And Get Quote