Negative Reactions to Affirmative Action Ten years ago, your company made an org

Question

Negative Reactions to Affirmative Action

Ten years ago, your company made an organization-wide commitment to increase diversity. Every single employee, from entry level clerks to senior executives, attended a two-weeklong diversity training course. After that course, a group of employees and managers formed a committee that met each week to talk about how to make sure that their workplace was one that respected and appreciated everyone’s uniqueness. Senior managers also create a new item in the budget. They call it "social affairs”, and it was a large pool of money that was to be used for holding group dinners, movie nights, weekend camping trips, and other social activities that were designed to help workers get to know each other better. A controversial part of this plan to encourage diversity had to do with hiring. After one particular company-wide training session, the senior management team came to the realization that the company lacked minorities. There were few African Americans, Latinos, or Asians among the employees, and even fewer women. Every single person on the senior management team was a Caucasian male, and there were only two minorities among 75 middle managers. After a series of conversations, the senior managers decided that the company would hire more minorities at all levels of the company and give them support and training they would need to get promotions.

In just ten short years, the company looks radically different. More than 50 percent of all employees are minorities and more than 30 percent of managers are African American or Latino. Women now make up just less than 50 percent of middle management, and three women were recently promoted to senior level positions.

Although the senior management team is elated with these developments, not all employees agree. A group of Caucasian male employees have been complaining for several months that they are the victims of reverse discrimination. They complain that they’ve been passed over for promotions, even though they’re the best qualified, in favor of minorities with lesser qualifications. They also argue that they receive far less training and coaching, that their performance reviews are much more critical, and they receive pay raises and bonuses far less frequently than those of their nonwhite, non-male colleagues.

As a group of white male employees explain to your senior management team, it’s not that they are against diversity. They want to do all they can to make this company a great place for diversity. But, they wonder, how does it help increase diversity if white men feel like they’re being discriminated against for being white men? That is the question they want you to answer.

Do you believe that companies should adopt affirmative action to increase their diversity?

Are there alternatives to affirmative action that a company can use to increase diversity?

Do you think that affirmative action is discriminatory towards white males? If so, is it an acceptable means of increasing diversity?

Explanation / Answer

In my views, affirmative actions were valid in the past but in current scenario where almost every organization is aiming to have a diverse workforce, affirmative actions should not be catered to for increasing diversity. This is because; this approach becomes biased to the existing majority in the organization, which is not correct. Diversity is not about employing bias and discrimination in the business policy. Merit must never suffer just to include diversity in business.

There are alternatives to affirmative action, which can be used to increase diversity at the workplace:

Though the aim was to increase diversity, the affirmative action indirectly became biased to the white males. Their merit and performance were ignored just to include diversity in business.

As discussed above, affirmative action is not an acceptable means of increasing diversity in the current business scenario. Merit and performance of a consistent performer must be considered for promotions. Similarly, in hiring practices, merit must never be compromised just to increase diversity at the workplace.

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse N
• Subjects

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.