Assume the following game is played one time only. Based on the information in t

Question

Assume the following game is played one time only. Based on the information in the payoff matrix below, PNC Bank and Citizens Bank are considering an implicit collusive agreement on interest rates. Payoffs to the two firms are represented in terms of profits in thousands of dollars.

Citizens Bank

Collude: Raise Rates

Defect: Keep Rates Where They Are

PNC

Collude: Raise Rates

(900, 600)

(700, 800)

Defect: Keep Rates Where They Are

(1100, 300)

(800, 400)

Does PNC have a dominant strategy? What is it?

Does Citizens have a dominant strategy? What is it?

Does the result of your answer change if the game is played an infinite number of times? Why or why not? Properly use game theoretic terminology in your answer

Citizens Bank

Collude: Raise Rates

Defect: Keep Rates Where They Are

PNC

Collude: Raise Rates

(900, 600)

(700, 800)

Defect: Keep Rates Where They Are

(1100, 300)

(800, 400)

Explanation / Answer

A dominant strategy is one which is optimal for a player no matter what the other player is playing.

1. In the above game, to find the dominant strategy of PNCs, we observe best response when Citizens Bank plays either of the two strategies. When Citizens Bank plays Collude, PNC maximizes its payoff by playing strategy Defect (1100>900) if Citizens Bank choses to play Defect, then PNC maximizes its payoff by choosing to Defect (800>700) . Thus, we conclude that PNC chooses to defect no matter what Citizens Bank plays, hence Defect is the dominant strategy of PNC in this game.

2. To find the dominant strategy of Citizens Bank we have to check its best response when PNC plays either of the two strategies.  When PNC plays Collude, Citizens Bank  maximizes its payoff by playing strategy Defect (800>600) if PNC plays Defect, then Citizens Bank maximizes its payoff by choosing to Defect (400>300).Hence Defect is the dominant strategy of Citizens Bankin this game.

Defect is the dominant strategy of both the players in this game. Thus, (Defect, Defect) is the nash equilibrium in this game.

3. The result may change when the game is played infinite number of times. When a game is played infinite number of times then one of the player may choose “Collude” , it may cost him in the the current game, but believing that if he chooses “Collude,” the other player will be more likely to also choose “Collude” in future plays of the game.If both PNC and Citizens bank choose to collude, then they can increase thier pay-off to (900,600) which is higher than (800,400).

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse A
• Subjects

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.