Can healthcare professionals override parental decision to withhold medical trea
ID: 241778 • Letter: C
Question
Can healthcare professionals override parental decision to withhold medical treatment? Should healthcare professionals be able to override parental decisions to withhold medical treatment?
Should parents be allowed to refuse medical treatment for their child?
Should minors be allowed consent to the follow services without parental notification: contraceptive services, testing and services for HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases, prenatal care and delivery services. Treatment for alcohol and drug abuse, mental health care.
Try to discuss each question including pros and cons, legality in California, moral and ethical concerns and your role in the health care industry in relation to these issues. 2000 word minimum.
Explanation / Answer
Introduction
Adults have the ability and legal right to take decisions about their health and treatment. But young children are unable to make complicated decisions regarding treatment by their own. The responsibility usually falls to the child’s parents.
Discussion
Can healthcare professionals override parental decisions to withhold medical treatment?
Parents are more responsible and accountable to make decisions regarding treatment on behalf of their children. They are accepting the treatment of refusing and discontinuing the treatment.
But, in some situations the health professionals can disagree or override parental advice if the child is not in good condition to take the decision by own physically and mentally. A health center and the health professionals are liable for their actions and they should be legally bonded with their institution policy that a patient should be taken care off till the patient expired
However In an emergency situation, when a child has a terminal illness with poor prognosis. Parents of the child do have a right to refuse treatment, In such cases the Doctors and other health professional should accept the parental decision in continuing health care services, because all parents have a right to select which is best for their children well being.
Should healthcare professionals be able to override parental decisions to withhold medical treatment?
The health care professionals and health care institutions are answerable to their approach about patient’s treatment. They have to explain all the availabilities of treatment for the particular condition. They have to make the parents to accept the treatment. On the other hand Doctors apply pick your battles approach. This goal is not achieved if they override parental decision for the medical treatment. The sufferer will be the child. So the doctors should maintain respectful and good relationship with parents
Pros and cons
If the health professionals do not accept the parent decision the parents will withdraw from contact with health professionals and institution, Children will not receive adequate care
Should parents be allowed to refuse medical treatment for their child?
All parents usually have the legal right to make decisions’ about medical treatment for their children. Parents have to sign in the informed consent before starting the treatment. However parents are basically better situated to know what their children need and which is the best option to give the most beneficial treatment from health services for their children.
American parents generally have the legal right to make medical decisions for their small children. As well as parents are eligible to raise their children according to their families own values and cultural beliefs, no one can involve in between unless until some thing creates harm for the children.
Should minors be allowed consent to the follow services without parental notification: contraceptive services, testing and services for HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases, prenatal care and delivery services. Treatment for alcohol and drug abuse, mental health care.
In some situations where minors can take medical treatment without parental consent. They are
According to Minor consent to medical treatment laws the minors are categorized and listed the conditions for what they can get medical benefits without their parents consent.
Although they are under the control the of their parents there are some exceptional cases which doesn’t require parent consent for adolescents’ for health care services such as sexually transmitted diseases, venereal diseases and other infectious diseases which causes social stigma and which need to be kept confidential
Legality in California
California also they have set a law to protect minor’s right to consent and confidentiality for particular situations and conditions such as Sexually transmitted diseases, Venereal diseases, pregnancy, Abortion, Substance abuse and some mental illness
Moral and ethical consent regarding the above statement
The ethical framework described those situations in which a health care professional is justified in overriding parental advice in medical treatment. It has a different moral concept that harm or best choice for the children. Whose decisions are harm to the children that should override
If the parental decision is harm to their children the health professional can override the parental advice in giving medical treatment since they are liable to their responsibilities. On the other hand if parent’s choices in the best interest for the children the health care profession can seek the lawful advice to follow or override in order to safeguard them and to protect the policy and human morals.
Conclusion
The health care professionals should be justified for their actions. They should seek legal advice in complicated cases in order to stand with in the ethical framework and human moral
Related Questions
drjack9650@gmail.com
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.