IS THIS THE REAL PURPOSE OF THE BANKRUPTCY LAWS? Insolvency is not a necessary c

Question

IS THIS THE REAL PURPOSE OF THE BANKRUPTCY LAWS?

Insolvency is not a necessary condition for bankruptcy. Moreover a firm may petition the court for protection under Chapter 11 even though it is not insolvent. If the business can demonstrate real financial trouble, the court will generally not dismiss the petition. In recent years, Chapter 11 has been looked upon as a safe harbor for gaining time to restructure the business and to head off more serious financial problems. For example, when Johns Manville filed a petition under Chapter 11, it was a profitable, financially sound company. Yet it faced numerous lawsuits for damages resulting from asbestos products it sold. Reorganization helped Johns Manville deal with its financial problems. [emphasis added]*

Over the years, the filing of a voluntary Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition has become a tool that companies sometimes use to settle significant financial problems. Just as Johns Manville reorganized to settle the claims of asbestos victims, A. H. Robins followed a similar path to resolve thousands of lawsuits stemming from injuries resulting from the Dalkon Shield intrauterine device. The Wilson Foods Corporation managed to reduce union wages by filing under Chapter 11, as did Continental Airlines Corporation.

Not surprisingly, seeking protection under Chapter 11 to force a bargained resolution of a financial difficulty is a controversial legal maneuver. Creditors and claimants often argue that this procedure is used to avoid responsibility. Companies counter that bankruptcy can become the only realistic means of achieving any settlement.

Should companies be allowed to use the provisions of Chapter 11 in this manner?

Explanation / Answer

Yes companies need to be allowed to use the provisions of chapter 11 in this manner, because, it gives the company an edge to get out of the problem of insolvency and bankruptcy and gives advantage to carry its liability in long run and this is an advantage to the company but

There is need for the restriction on usage of the provisions of chapter 11, which it must not be used in case of

Health and safety of community

The provisions must not harm the community at large

Unless and otherwise every ones interest need to be protected and

By claiming the provisions company must not damage the interests of its stake holders and

The legal suits must be of genuine nature, that if criminal nature is not involved.

Decision has to be changed according to the facts of each case, there is need for analysis and investigation for claiming the provisions of chapter and decision has to be taken according to the circumstances

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse I
• Subjects

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.