The first seminar is schedule for two weeks from today. Ms. Field would like you

Question

The first seminar is schedule for two weeks from today. Ms. Field would like you to prepare for the seminar by reviewing the structure of the court in your state, jurisdiction, and the various sources of law. She would like you to prepare a chart demonstrating the court structure and jurisdiction, and prepare a memo about the sources of law and ethics. Ms. Field will be using the following fact pattern to demonstrate the sources of law and ethics:

Phyllis Smith owns and manages a restaurant in the community, Lucky Horseshoe Restaurant. Ann Reid lives next door to the restaurant. Ms. Reid filed a complaint with the police department that the patrons of the restaurant and referred to them as “drunks” and “whores.” She picked fights with the bartender on several occasions and even called him Satan. These encounters happened in the presence of the patrons of the restaurant. Sales dropped 30% and Ms. Smith filed a law suit against Reid.

Compose a memo that Ms. Field will use to present at this seminar. The memo will respond to the following questions:

Analyze and discuss the four sources of primary law, and identify which source of law may be applicable to this case being certain to explain why.

Discuss whether Reid’s statements about the restaurant’s owner, bartender, and customers are protected by the U.S. Constitution.

Evaluate whether Reid behaved unethically in the circumstances of this case. Explain why.

Explanation / Answer

Summary of the case:

1. The first seminar is schedule for two weeks from today, Ms. Field would like you to prepare
for the seminar by reviewing the structure of the court in the state, jurisdiction and the various sources of law.

2. Ms. Field will be using the following fact pattern to demonstrate the sources of laws and ethics

3. Phylis smith owns and manages a restaurent in the community, lucky horeshoe restaurant and Ann reid lives next door to the restaurent

4. Ms. Reid filed a complaint with the police department that the patrons of the restaurant and
refferes to the, as drunks and whores she picked fights with the bartender on several occasions and even called him satan.

5. These enconters happended in the presence of the patrons of the restaurants and the Sales dropped 30% so Ms.Smith filed a suit againt reid.

Answers:

1 Ans:
1. Custom law
2. Religion and Morality
3. Equity Law
4. Judicial Decisions
Equity Law: this laws is applicable here, as the name itself states that everyone are equal, so
here the member in the court should hear both the answers at every individual perspective
before taking any decision. This law will help to maintain a fair play and justice in this
situation.

2 Ans: Yes, according to U.S constitution Ms. Reid statement is completely protected. As the U.S
constitution helps in stating those three words “We The People” which wisely frames the balanced government laws for every individual.

3 Ans: Yes, Ms. Reid behaviour is unethical as she shouldn’t react in such a way. If she wants to make a complaint against the Hoseshoe restaurent, she should adopt a perfect complaining procedure with the help of police and should raise her voice. Because of her behaviour that restaurent sales dropped down to 30%.

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse T
• Subjects

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.