The above information comes from Ethical Decision Making in the Hospitality Indu

Question

The above information comes from Ethical Decision Making in the Hospitality Industry. Read Case Study Analysis (Analyzing Cases) Pages 33-40 and Case Study "Swim Up Pool Frank" (Pages 270-274), To complete Ethical Analysis Forms (2 pages).

Ethical Analysis Form - Swim Up Pool Frank Name fter reading the Case Study Analysis on pages 33-40 and "Swim Up Pool Frank" on pages 270-274, you can complete the form below. ing the example from page39-40 as a basis, complete the questions and chart below in reference to "Swim Up Pool Frank." Two beginning questions should be at least 3-5 sentences each: 1. What was the problem in "Swim Up Pool Frank"? hat are 2-3 options for John to solve the problem? After you identified 2-3, chose one to complete the questions and chart below. Apply the case study questions from page 35 of textbook to "Swim Up Pool Frank." These should NOT be one sentence answers, but instead fully supported answers. Include ethical theories and principles to your answers if applicable. For Questions 5-7, complete the chart as seen on pages 39-40. To help you, I have started the chart. However, because I did not suggest a decision not determine the consequences for John. (see question #2 above), I can 1. What was the person in the case (John) trying to accomplish? 2. Is what the person in the case (John) trying to accomplish ethical? 3. What are the possible decision options? 4. Where do the person's loyalties belong? 5. Who are the stakeholders who could be affected by the decision (put in chart)? 6. What are the possible consequences to all the stakeholders for the final decision (put in chart)? 7. Are there any of the 10 ethical principles that might be violated by any of the decision option (put in chart)?

Explanation / Answer

Ans1. The problem faced in swim up pool frank was that the biys wanted to build a pool bar which needed building permit as the structure was going to be installed from below ground level . On application of the permit the inspector had come for survey and found an issue for which the building permit could not be granted.

Ans2. Options in front of Jhon:

Ans1. In the above case jhon wanted to build a pool bar for which the structure had to build from below ground level. Since a renovation was under process jhon required the building permit. on inspection of the place and blueprints the inspector found problems due to which he could not give the work permit to jhon. Jhon wanted the building permit and was wiling to bribe the inspector inorder to receive the same. he was trying to accomplish his need for pool bar by illegal and unethical means which could have severe consiquences if went south.

Ans2. Jhon is trying to acomplish building a structure which does not have legal building permit and wishes to acquire the same by bribeing the inspector. The deed which is he is trying to do is illegal and unethical in all means. here jhon is violating ethical principles like Accountability, concern for others, honesty etc. creating a structure which is not permited can lead to dangerous situations; bribing a goverment official is a crime in itself and can lead to staining his reputation.

Ans3. The possible decision options are as follows:

Ans4. The loyalties belong to himself only and not towards the concern of others. here jhon is having a mayopic sight where is he only concerned with his form of entertainment by building the pool bar in any means possible overlooking the safety concerns of himself and others.

Ans 5, 6 and 7 are mentioned below in the chart:

The decision here taken is that Jhon has taken the permit the right way by finding out the problem and providing the solution for the same leading to building of the pool bar.

Honesty

Fairness

Accountability

Reputation and morale

Honesty

Fairness

Accountability

Reputation and morale

Honesty

integrity

accountability

Stakeholders principles consequences Jhon

Honesty

Fairness

Accountability

Reputation and morale

• here jhon will be able to have what he needs in the right manner
• everyone will be happy
• ethically and morally he has achieved what he wanted
• safety concerns are taken into consideration

Sam riley

Honesty

Fairness

Accountability

Reputation and morale

• Sam riley will be violating principles as he wants to give permit in exchange of bribe
• if Jhon finds out the problem and solves it then sam will not receive any bribe
• he can complain against him and get his reputation into problem
• He is accountable for the safety of the people

Hidie

Honesty

integrity

accountability

• as hidie is accompanying jhon she can guide him to do the right and ethical thing
• She will be honest and try to find the solution of the problem rather than bribeing
• she will be accountable for the safety of people

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse T
• Subjects

---

---

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.