First read about the incident in the NY Times article David Howard. Answer quest
ID: 430459 • Letter: F
Question
First read about the incident in the NY Times article David Howard. Answer question 1,2 below.
The denotative meaning of a word is the dictionary definition. A connotative meaning is what people think of or feel when they hear a word based on past associations or experiences.
The denotative meanings of the word niggardly include: 1. Very reluctant to give or spend anything. 2. Very small or inadequate in quantity. The connotative meaning may contain some association to the racial slur, which sounds similar, but has a completely different history and denotative meaning.
In 1999 David Howard, a top aid of the Washington Mayor who is Caucasian, used the word niggardly in a meeting. He said, “I will have to be niggardly with this fund because it's not going to be a lot of money.” Many people were offended by Howard’s use of the word niggardly. Ultimately he resigned.
Think about the word and the particular event, and then post your responses to these questions.
1. Do you think it was right for Howard to be pressured into resigning? Support your response.
2. How did language and critical thinking figure into this situation?
Explanation / Answer
1. It wasn't right for Howard to be pressured into resigning. He was just using the denotative meaning of the word "niggardly" and not the connotative one. Instead of forcing him to resign, asking him for an apology would have been sufficient Pressurising him to resign is quite extreme.
2. Howard's use of the word "niggardly" to explain the shortage of funds is not incorrect when looked from the point of view of language. However, it is his duty to understand his audience before delivering a speech. Not everyone would be familiar with the denotative meaning of the word. Unless the audience are intellectuals or well educated and have a rich vocabulary, using such words with normal people will definitely lead to controversies. So, it can be said that Howard lacked the critical thinking required to deliver the speech.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.