A plane makes an emergency crash landing on a deserted tropical island. Two doze

Question

A plane makes an emergency crash landing on a deserted tropical island. Two dozen survivors must fend for themselves until help arrives. All of them are from large cities, and none of them has camping experience. The survivors find it impossible to gather enough food, and everyone begins losing weight. One person spends a lot of time by himself and figures out how to catch fish. He brings fish back to camp. Others ask him to teach them how to catch fish. He refuses, but offers to share the fish he has caught with the other passengers as long as they take care of the other camp chores, such as hauling fresh water, gathering firewood, and cooking.

Debate the morality of the bargain proposed by the fisherman.

5 Debate Points for ==>The fisherman’s position is morally wrong.

5 Debate Points for ==>The fisherman’s position is morally acceptable.

Explanation / Answer

The fisherman's position is morally wrong:

The fisherman's position is morally acceptable:

Five points against the fisherman's position could be: Is motivated by selfishness; Is not out of responsibility or duty: Would be bring hierarchy in the Camp regarding the daily chores; There could be conflict and tension in the Camp due the dominance and resistance against it: Would give more authority and power to fisherman.

Five points for the fisherman's position; Happiness in the camp: More good towards all: Would prevent choas if everybody go for fishing: Would ensure the longer sustenance of people in the camp: Would bring order and regularity in the camp.

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse A
• Subjects

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.