Discuss the following case study by addressing the set of questions raised below
ID: 1218909 • Letter: D
Question
Discuss the following case study by addressing the set of questions raised below. In making ethical analysis, make use of at least two Ethical Theories (utilitarianism, duty ethics, virtue ethics) and point out two set of codes from the NSPE code of ethics Signings of Drawings by Engineer in Industry Engineer A is employed by a computer manufacturing company. She was responsible for the design of certain computer equipment several years ago. She signed off on the drawings for the equipment at that time. Although Engineer A's design was properly prepared, the equipment-manufacturing process was faulty and, as a result the equipment became too costly and suffered mechanical breakdown. The manufacturing division made a number of recommended modifications to her design that is believed would help reduce costs in the manufacturing process. Engineer A's analysis of the manufacturing division's recommendations revealed that they would reduce the reliability of the product and greatly increase the downstream costs to the company through warrant claims. Engineer A's supervisor, who is not an engineer, asks Engineer A to sign off on the changes for the new computer equipment. There is nothing to suggest that the equipment would pose a danger to the public health and safety. Engineer A raises her concerns to her supervisor but nevertheless agrees to sign off on the changes without further protest. Did Engineer A fulfill her ethical obligation by signing off on the changes without further action?Explanation / Answer
Engineer A is the one who is entrusted to sign design the product, She did her duty.
Later on she was pretty sure that manufacturer recommendations are not good, She still signed the document, The issue here is when she is sure that new design mods are not in the interest of the company she must resist such changes and more importantly never sign the document.
It is very important for any person who is signing the document to fully understand the implications of such signature, If you sign something you will be hold responsible for problems in future.
The engineer could have asked her superior to sign the document himself, So any future problem would be faced by manager himself, She did not follow proper procedure.
Related Questions
drjack9650@gmail.com
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.