Read the story of Ron Houben, who was seemingly brought back from the dead, than
ID: 123966 • Letter: R
Question
Read the story of Ron Houben, who was seemingly brought back from the dead, thanks to medical technology. Post your responses to the following questions.
1.The Glasgow Coma Scale was used to assess Mr. Houben. Do you think using the Harvard Criteria would result in a different assessment?
2.What role does/should medical technology play in determining whether to remove someone from life support?
3.Are the Glasgow Coma Scale and the Harvard Criteria absolute? In other words, do you think there’s room for doubt using these scales?
4.How should technology be used to determine or define death?
Explanation / Answer
1, The Harvard criteria and Glassgow coma scale are of similar in assessment. The Harvard criteria also assess the eye response, responsiveness, receptivity, reflexes, movement. So there is not much difference in assesing the MR Houben.
2, To determine whether to remove someone from life support plays acucial role. The medical technology also plays a role along with ethical aspect. The health condition can be assesed by using PET scan and ECMO. They brought new challenges to the end of life care. Those helps to identify the brain activity as well as patients responsiveness to the treatment. Whether the cellular activity is reacting or not. Based on this, the medical technology helps to identify whether to continue or remove the client from lifes upport
3, Glassgow coma scale and Harvard criteria are of absolutely similar. The assesment is of similar in both sclaes. The criteria are,
Harvard criteria asssessment:
A series of 4 parameters delineated by Harvard medical school for irresversible coma,
Harvard criteria for brain death-
In addition following must be present,
Body temperature >_32C
Absence of CNS depressant
Glassgow coma scale:
Glassgow coma scale assess the level of consciousness and reaction to stimuli based on eye opening, verbal response performance and motor responsiveness.
The Glassgow coma scale and Harvard criteria are of sbsolutely similar, there is no room for doubt using these scales. The aim of both scales is to identify responsiveness, receptivity, movement, reflexes.
4, Technology should be used to determine or define death:
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.