DEBATING THE PAST RECONSTRUCTION Debate over the nature of Reconstruction of Rec
ID: 802956 • Letter: D
Question
DEBATING THE PAST RECONSTRUCTION Debate over the nature of Reconstruction of Reconstruction ds those in the nove and has been unusually intense. Indeed, few film Wind, issues in American history have raised such deep and enduring passions American scholar, offered one of the frst Beginning in the late nineteenth century alternative views and continuing well into the twentieth, arela- 935). To Du Bois, Reconstruction was an tively uniform and highly critical view of effort by freed blacks (and their Reconstruction prevailed among historians to cre more democratic society in the and Dunning's South it for valu Economic (1907 was the principal able social innovations. In the early 1 portrayed this Dunning Hope Stampp. Reconstruction as a corrupt a building on a generation of work by other oppressive outrage imposed on a prostrate scholars, published new histories of Recon- South by a vindictive group of Northern also radically revised the baggers flooded the South and plundered argued, was a genuine, te, effort region. Ignorant and unfit African to solve the problem of race he South Reconstruction omkes. Radicals corruption and governments were awash in they were genuinely concerned compiled enormous levels tecting the were not saints, but of debt. The Dunning interpretation domi ryhts slaves Recon or stnution had brought im portant arship and helped shape such popular images to there than was evident no more corruption in the North at the same time. What was he argues, can only be judged a tailure' as an tragic about Reconstruction, the revison. efort sts claimed it rights as citizens and hites but what it failed free offeven more was, in the to do for Southern presivealternatives....The post-Reconstruc short-lived to end. Do weak and too guarantee African genuine equality. he closely supervised gang labor of In more recent years, some the and have begun to question historians immobluation of black labor force and the assessment of he systems coercive the first revisionists that, in the end, white Southernersin 1865 and 1866 The Reconstruction accomplished relatively it- doors of economic opportunity that had tle, Leon Litwack argued in Bern is the Store opened could never be completelyclosed" to ofered them UNDERSTAND, ANALYzE, & EvALUATE carve out a certain level of independence for themselves within Southern society: LWhat are the popular interpretations ng churches reuniting families, of Reconstruction today? Do romanti. and resisting the efforts of white puntersto cized ideas of benighted old south, revive the gang labor system as seen inCoer with the Wind, still Eric Foner's Reconstruction Anerice's penist? finshed Revolution (988) and Formm Fer 2 Anew view of Reconstruction began to emphasized how far African emerge in the 1960s, the end of the civl rights movement. Why do you Americans moved toward freedom andinde hink the civl rights movement might pendence in a short time and how important have encouraged historians and others were in shaping the evoution of to reexamine Reconstruction? Reconstruction polkie Reconstruton. The circumstances ef Lincoln's death canned him immediate martyrdom, They also produced summething close loExplanation / Answer
Ans 1:
In present time it has been suggested to interpret reconstruction not in terms of what has it achieved for the upliftment of southern blacks but to analyze the empowerment it provided to the native people by means of strengthening of their rights and creating labor reforms.
The old school of thought with reference to reconstruction as highlighted by “Gone with the wind” does not hold true in the present time, but it has been replaced by the ideals of democratic rights and social and economic empowerment.
Ans 2.
The idea of the reconstruction was initially based on the oppression of the black people; however with the civil right movement the ideas began to reinvent. The basic fact is that the civil right movement was largely focused on providing the fundamental rights of life, employment and expression. Thus given the implementation of the rights to citizens any reconstruction needs to take in consideration the assessment of the rights empowerment of the deprived citizens. Thus the civil rights movement may encourage the historians to reinvent and measuring the reconstruction in terms of empowerment.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.